College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students

Viewpoint: Reasons for the DREAM Act

By Jillian Sheridan

Daily Texan Editorial Board

Print this article

Published: Thursday, September 24, 2009

Updated: Thursday, September 24, 2009

Yesterday, students here and across the nation rallied in support of the Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors Act, a federal measure that would afford undocumented students in the U.S. a path to citizenship. If passed, the act will benefit undocumented students who have graduated from high school or received a GED, lived in the U.S. at least five years, entered the country before the age of 16, compiled no criminal record and demonstrated “good moral character.”


Under the DREAM Act, youths who meet these requirements would be granted conditional permanent residency, an already existing form of legal residency that would allow them to legally drive, work and have access to federal aid.

Conditional permanent residency is re-evaluated after six years, and during the six years, students would be required to obtain a minimum of a two-year college degree or complete two years of military service. At the end of the six years, their cases would be reviewed, and — if they completed the college or military requirements without a criminal record — they would be granted lawful permanent residency. They would then be eligible to pursue U.S. citizenship.


Undocumented youths in America currently have no means by which they can work toward U.S. citizenship. Those moved to the U.S. by their parents before the age of 16 are left to choose between a life of constant fear of government attention and returning to a country they hardly know in order to undergo a lengthy and tedious application for legal admittance to the U.S., which can be denied.


Members of the Federation for American Immigration Reform, a national nonprofit organization that aims to improve border security, denounce the DREAM Act as “amnesty for illegal aliens.” They claim the act would provide an incentive for additional undocumented immigrants to enter the U.S.


This rationale is inane. The numerous undocumented aliens who have entered the U.S. in the past have not done so out of anticipation of their children one day finding success under the DREAM Act, nor will the many underprivileged and persecuted people who will seek entrance to our country need it as an incentive tomorrow.


The act simply allows those who were brought here without a choice, have lived here, been brought up through our education system and have proven themselves to be decent citizens an opportunity to work toward becoming official contributors to our society as educated citizens or members of the military.


Texas, especially, has much to gain through the DREAM Act. With a large population of undocumented immigrants, Texas will benefit from an influx of degree-holding citizens able to legally enter the workforce.


There is no reason to deny those whose only crime was being carried across the border a route to the full benefits this country offers. Congress would be wise to provide this reasonable path for them to find their way out of America’s shadows and afford them the benefits and responsibilities of full citizenship.
 

Comments

19 comments
nomad
Tue Oct 27 2009 17:43
DREAM ACT all the way, it will only benefit this country!!!
no we can't
Tue Oct 20 2009 11:56
Illegal aliens can already go to college, they do not deserve to pay in-state tuition. Do not reward children for their parents criminal behavior.
Your name
Mon Sep 28 2009 16:37
Garsh... you and Britanicus and this guy "Martinez" should join and form a Paranoia club
Garsh
Sun Sep 27 2009 12:03
No. No way. Fight the dilution of your culture, and resist the browning of America.
Mike
Fri Sep 25 2009 22:37
Pass the Dream Act in October!!!
...It will benefit our damage Economy.
George Lopez
Thu Sep 24 2009 22:34
I support the DREAM ACT because I believe in higher education for all the students that have been in the USA for more than 6 years. If they have learned English and have our American values, I say let them work. They need to start paying for my social security and medicare ASAP.
George Lopez
Thu Sep 24 2009 22:34
I support the DREAM ACT because I believe in higher education for all the students that have been in the USA for more than 6 years. If they have learned English and have our American values, I say let them work. They need to start paying for my social security and medicare ASAP.
Kayla Smith
Thu Sep 24 2009 22:25
The DREAM ACT is a stimulus policy. As president OBAMA said in his address to congress, creating an educated workforce will stimulate our economy, increase productivity and help the U.S. compete in the global company. Students who would benefit from the DREAM Act are future teachers,doctors, nurses, and lawyers. The DREAM ACT will allow immigrant students to access higher education and maximize their contributions to our economy and communities
Educated Longhorn
Thu Sep 24 2009 22:19
I am amazed how many ignorant people are in our campus. You think that you are exercising your freedom of speech, yet you are conveying your racism and xenophobic ideologies. The DREAM ACT can only benefit our country, these students are paying for their education, they worked hard to be at UT. This is AMERICA the land of opportunities, we are all immigrants. I support the DREAM ACT because it will help our country with the shortage of professions and these students will have the opportunity to start paying taxes. I SUPPORT THE DREAM ACT.
Joe White
Thu Sep 24 2009 22:10
The DREAM ACT will enhance our national security because we will have proper documentation of who is in our country. I support the DREAM ACT because many of my friends are in this situation. We have classes together, they do lots of volunteer work, they speak perfect English and we share the same values. In other words, they have been acculturated and assimilated. They have worked very hard to graduate from high school and they have the tenacity to do something positive in their lives. They are our fellow classmates and they need our support.
Leonard Martinez
Thu Sep 24 2009 22:07
I've got a great idea. Anyone born anywhere in the world is automatically a US citizen. Citizenship doesn't mean anything anymore anyway. The 1964 Immigration Reform Act opened the door to massive legal immigration that has resulted in multitudes of ethnic enclaves across the nation, and you can never have too much diversity. I say let's continue to Balkanize by passing the DREAM Act, and if you're not for it, you are probably a KKK member or a Nazi. It's that simple. Either you're for it, or you're a racist Nazi Ku Klux Klansman. Brittanicus is all three. So open the floodgates and let everybody in. There's lots of land here to develop, and lots of money to be made. Civil War Battlefield sites offer great locations for condo development, and the new immigrant majority doesn't give a rat's patootie about Old America stuff like that. It's a brand-new country, and the sooner the xenophobes realize that they're the foreigners, the sooner we can blow the roof off.
Good Bless America
Thu Sep 24 2009 19:46
Wow this Britanicus guy sure is paranoid and xenophobic. I cannot believe people like him exist in the world. I support the DREAM Act because it make sense. I wonder how the USA will lose culturally and financially by adopting kids who love America and not only that but who are culturally rich and professionals in their respective fields and would contribute greatly to the American Society if given the chance of doing so. It makes sense economically and morally the DREAM Act feels right. Mr. Britanicus take your hating and xenophobic rhetoric so antiquated for our time to another message board like the KKK for instance and even though you are entitled to your opinion not everybody thinks like you.

Keep fighting for your DREAMs guys!! me and the majority of the US population I am sure support you and Mr. Powers should endorse the DREAM Act.

Brittanicus
Thu Sep 24 2009 19:31
There should be emphasis on E-Verify being adopted by every business in America, mandatory or not? Now that it’s locked into the US workers psyche, it should be evident to the pro-illegal immigrant groups that--THE PEOPLE--are not letting go of this computer illegal immigrant enforcement application without a fight. It has been ridiculed and ostracized by the US Chamber of Commerce and subjected to federal lawsuits by the anti-sovereignty groups as the ACLU. I'm not one for conspiracy theories, but when the Council of Foreign Relation intolerable globalist and internationalists get involved with America’s immigration face-off, you really wonder what their true agenda is? GOOGLE-- across the Internet and understand their plan for the free flow of low income labor in every available industry including Agricultural jobs.

This quasi agency was the machine involved with the inception of NAFTA. Coincidentally, I recall that President Obama and his administration addressed the general public that he would renegotiate the treaties of NAFTA and CAFTA? So far this has not materialized, nor has his promise to implement an open transparent government? He is following the same illusory lines as the Bush presidency, other than National security--remaining secretive?

E-Verify is a very powerful immigration tool that is a composite of the SAVE ACT. Around the country it's building in momentum as more and more companies are intending to use it? It could additionally have multiple future uses, including detecting illegal aliens applying for driver’s licenses. It could also be adapted to apprehend any foreign nationals who apply in any health care reform or any other government benefit. By overturning the 1986 Immigration legislation and enacting a new AMNESTY the American population lose culturally and financially. Another possibility is checking the status of individuals admitted to higher education or schools. Its availability is a free service on the web, by accessing both Homeland Security and the Social Security databases. On an ongoing basis it is seemingly the principle tool to detour anybody who is stealing jobs from the legal population.

It almost succumbed to Democratic leadership, because both Sen Reid and Pelosi had an ulterior motive to kill E-Verify and other immigration enforcement weapons. Having massive illegal immigrant occupation in both Nevada and California and an escalating need to financially support the millions already thriving in all Border States. YOU CAN HELP AMERICAN WORKERS IN THIS JOBLESS SETTINGS AND HALT ANY NEW AMNESTY BY CONTACTING YOUR POLITICIANS AT 202-224-3121. NUMBERSUSA, JUDICIAL WATCH & CAPSWEB have many of the true answers for you to decide.

Dreamer
Thu Sep 24 2009 12:16
Of the many articles i have searched and read today about this same topic, this is the first one that has no negative comments about this bill. I would be one of those benefited with the passing of this bill. I am currently in my second year of college (community) and hope to transfer to a University in 1 1/2 - 2 years. The reason i didn't go straight to a University was because of tuition costs. Hopefully when i am ready to transfer this bill would have passed and be in effect so i can afford going to a University. Thanks to all who support the bill.
TX_TAXPAYER
Thu Sep 24 2009 12:00
FAIR, the Federation for American Immigration Reform, has employed white supremacists in key leadership roles, has accepted over a million dollars from a eugenics foundation AND, as if that weren’t enough, has helped to bolster racist conspiracy theories throughout the country.

FAIR is not the voice of the mainstream, it’s the voice of individuals who have helped fuel the 40% increase in the number of hate groups in the US. These aren’t citizen advocacy groups, or simply groups of concerned folk- they are hate groups plain and tall.

A recent report by the Southern Poverty Law Center, outlines the story of FAIR as a hate group, and it justifies their official addition to the national list of hate groups maintained by the organization.

ACRONYM
Thu Sep 24 2009 10:01
The DREAM Act (I'm amused by the concurrent use of "alien" in the acronym and "undocumented" in the description, but I digress) is probably one of the least-bad immigration proposals with a realistic chance of passing. That's not to say it's even necessarily an improvement, but it at least imposes some substantial minimum requirements to remain in the country legally after the initial six year period. Of the four requirements (no criminal activity, military service, completed undergraduate degree, two years completed of an undergraduate degree) I'd say that the last is the weakest, and probably shouldn't be included. Two years of an undergraduate degree really isn't acceptable in a six year window, particularly given that these students would be eligible for federally originated loans (though not grants). I'd be more understanding if one had to work through the whole degree without assistance.

Other than that, carry on. The people passing the bill are counting on beneficiaries' future votes, and really, is importing a different demographic to vote for you much different than redrawing district lines to choose your own voters? Well, maybe a little.

Will T.
Thu Sep 24 2009 03:42
A lot of people would be against this bill because of the idea of awarding bad behavior would lead to more bad behavior. I believe that coming to this country illegally is wrong, which would lead many to believe that deportation is a valid solution for these kids. While politically this may seem right, the American values of compassion and understanding of the situation of these kids (putting myself in their shoes) leads me to believe that the denial of Education, Life, and Liberty from these folks is ethically wrong. God Bless, I HOPE the DREAM ACT will get pass soon!
ImfromA&M
Thu Sep 24 2009 02:39
The DREAM act is a great idea for America, I sure hope this bill passes.
Anon
Thu Sep 24 2009 01:17
Good read, hope to hear more about this subject.






log out