College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students

Professor links racism, language in guest lecture

By Priscilla Totiyapungprasert

Daily Texan Staff

Print this article

Published: Thursday, October 22, 2009

Updated: Thursday, October 22, 2009

When Mark McPhail, an interdisciplinary studies professor at Southern Methodist University, asks his students how they know what they know, he’s looking to solve problems.

McPhail asks for the kind of self-realization that he says is key to solving today’s social problems such as racism, sexism and other prejudices.

McPhail spoke about the relationship between racism and rhetoric in a lecture Wednesday afternoon at the College of Communication. The professor has published several books and essays on the topic of rhetoric, including “The Rhetoric of Racism Revisited: Reparations or Separation?”

In his lecture, McPhail explained how language creates reality and plays a key part in transforming social injustices.

People can begin to engage in the behaviors that others ascribe to them, for better or for worse.

“If we describe people different from ourselves by using terms that are negative, sometimes people accept those definitions,” McPhail said. “This is a complex subject that we really need to study to understand.”

McPhail said it was easy for people to claim to be anti-racist, but it’s the conscious decisions they make on a daily basis, including how they treat others, that should act as a barometer.

Much of racism derives from people simply not recognizing their own racism, McPhail said. People also use the term “post-racial” to falsely claim that racial problems no longer exist, he added. 

People cannot hold themselves accountable until they leave the confines of the classroom and have real-life experiences with people who are different from themselves, he said.

“White people have never really acknowledged there are racial problems,” he said. “A few have, but it’s people of color who mostly raise these issues. Just like how mostly women raise issues about sexism and the men believe themselves to not be sexist.”

Using alcoholism as an example, McPhail said that similar to alcoholics, racists must acknowledge the problem before they can overcome it. The only way to overcome is to face the problem in a real-life situation, he said.

“It cannot be solved through education,” McPhail said. “If I suffer from neurosis, I have to go to a therapist. I don’t go to a teacher. A teacher can’t teach me to not be neurotic.”

Comments

8 comments
Leonard Martinez
Sun Oct 25 2009 19:26
So if I can't recognize my own racism, how do you know I'm racist?

Everybody's racist to one degree or another. It's human nature, and even the hack that's bloviating in the article above is racist. I say so f**king what? There are worse things than being racist. Being a self-righteous pharisee like McPhail is one of them.

Why do you see the speck that is in your brother's eye but do not notice the log that is in your own eye?

Kris
Sat Oct 24 2009 09:52
I am confused. If we are all apparently a little racist (you can sing along now the avenue q song), then how am I supposed to know I am racist?

"Much of racism derives from people simply not recognizing their own racism, McPhail said"

So if I can't recognize my own racism, how do you know I'm racist? And how do I become unracist? And this article talked much about language in the beginning and even the title, but fails to give examples. Please, let me know my racist language so I can become unracist!

Leonard Martinez
Thu Oct 22 2009 19:31
It cannot be solved through education. If I suffer from neurosis, I have to go to a therapist. I don’t go to a teacher. A teacher can’t teach me to not be neurotic.

Now, now bitter people. These are words of wisdom from today's mighty university and the hacks that teach there. You white people need therapy to exorcise the demons that make you so odious to all people of color. Either that or turn your country over to them. Perhaps they'll forgive you and treat you kindly.

Paul Noble
Thu Oct 22 2009 18:30
Professors get paid to study this crap and then go around giving talks and making more money.
Deal me in.
Forget it
Thu Oct 22 2009 16:49
The U.S. is a melting-pot of every ethnic group on Earth. Many ethnic groups (e.g. Irish, Chinese) could reasonably lay claim to "reparations" for the way their particular ethnic group was treated on arrival in centurys past. Every day, the U.S. operates on borrowed money and sinks further into insolvency. Reparations? Forget about it.
Robert
Thu Oct 22 2009 14:49
"“White people have never really acknowledged there are racial problems,” he said." Balderdash. We fought not only the bloodiest war in our history of slavery, mostly white people giving their lives, but most of our domestic politics has been focused upon these issues for 50 years now. Typical professorial-elitism on display. He sees the problems but the great unwashed do not. Silly, it's the great unwashed who deal with the hard hitting nature of these problems in our neighborhoods and workplaces daily.
Mustafa Ansari
Thu Oct 22 2009 13:31
'first let me congratulate the professor, for his comments and efforts to discuss the issue.

Racism has an economical component that can only be rectified by an international human restorative remedy, commonly referred to as reparations. Reparations is a 28 point remedy ( See UN General Assembly Resolution 60/147) that entails, liberty/self-determination/land and housing set asides, mental rehabilitation, indigenous land rights as African Americans are indigenous, educational overhaul as the teachers and books glorify the American occupation.

American racism has a remedy under international law, our problem is implementation as the Barack Obama administration and the Jewish block has blocked talks in Geneva, and the American media has blocked this information.. see www.definingchange.us and the article by Naomi Klien in August Harpers Weekly. I have written a book about reparations under international law and I am available for lectures on the subject.

Leonard Martinez
Thu Oct 22 2009 10:00
White people have never really acknowledged there are racial problems....Just like how mostly women raise issues about sexism and the men believe themselves to not be sexist.

Translation: White heterosexual males are evil. And this is what passes for intellectual discourse in today's university. Can it get any more boring and uninspiring than this?







log out