College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students

Covered life gives new perspective

By Ana McKenzie

Daily Texan Staff

Print this article

Published: Friday, June 5, 2009

Updated: Friday, June 5, 2009

Spencer Wall

Mary Kang/The Daily Texan

Spencer Wall, fourth-year English and sociology major, talks about her experience wearing a hijab on Wednesday night at Kerbey Lane Cafe. Wall, a Christian from West Texas, embarked on a personal experience in which she dressed as a Muslim woman for a year, starting in April.

I first noticed Spencer Wall in my religion and society class toward the end of last semester. She wasn’t particularly outspoken, but the shawl that covered her hair, neck and shoulders made her stand out in the large class.

I usually gave her nothing more than a completely unconscious glance. But when she revealed to the class the decision that she made on April 27, I suddenly became aware of the attention I gave her.

Wall, a 20-year-old sociology and English senior, decided to assume the characteristics and attire of a “typical” Muslim woman for a year starting in late April.

She wears the traditional veil, or “hijab,” and loose-fitting clothing everywhere she goes and does not consume pork or alcohol in public. She avoids eye and physical contact with men and has adopted modest habits like walking with her arms glued to her sides or crossed in front of her to hide her chest. 

I witnessed the looks Wall gets on a daily basis when we met at Kerbey Lane on the Drag recently.  

She’s wearing a hijab splashed with vibrant shades of green and blue. A long-sleeved, black shirt and floor-length aqua skirt reveals only a few inches of skin.

 Some who pass us try to be inconspicuous with their intrigue, limiting themselves to quick side glances. But most don’t even try to be candid with their exaggerated double-takes or blatant stares.

She passes by a group waiting to be seated, and all of them stare at the back of her head as she walks away. One guy even rolls his eyes.

“It doesn’t surprise me,” she says when I tell her about the group. “But look around. They’re not the only ones.”

She insists her decision is not a social experiment but more of a personal learning experience. As a white female from a small, West Texas town, Wall says she wanted to know what it would be like to be part of a “noticeable minority.”

“I’m not representing Muslim women or the Muslim community,” she says. “I just want to know what it’s like to walk in their shoes for a while.”

Initially, Wall elaborates on her “learning experience” when people would ask her questions, the most common being “So, where are you from?” She has abandoned these efforts. Now, when people ask about her attire, she simply says she is not Muslim but wears the hijab because she chooses to do so.

This explanation is not entirely untrue, as Wall admits to not being able to leave her home without the clothing. 

“I decided a while ago that I was going to try and not wear the hijab for 24 hours,” she says. “I couldn’t even make it for half that.”

Wall says she receives different reactions when she wears the hijab. A man once fell into a display at Wal-Mart because he was staring at her. One day a group of male patrons at the restaurant where she works refused to be served by her. The same group called her derogatory names. But most of the time she said she is just respectfully avoided.

“I wouldn’t say guys don’t hit on me, but they do so in a very different way now,” she says. “It’s more respectful, less forward.”

The experience has taught Wall to pay attention to smaller details that would make a traditional Muslim lifestyle difficult to follow in the United States.

One day at a clothing store, Wall had to ask for a sheet to cover a gap between the floor and dressing room door so she could hide her bare legs as she changed. Her job as a waitress presents one of the most awkward situations as it naturally entails a lot of physical contact with strangers, which is not allowed for Muslim women, she said. 

Wall has grown to appreciate this sort of privacy and, in some ways, respect it. Perhaps the most unexpected outcome of the experience is a newfound devotion to her Christian faith. The Islamic faith requires followers to pray five times a day, the first prayer being at 5 a.m. Though Wall has not yet assumed this tradition, she admits she may in the future, and finds herself praying more often.

“You know we live in a society that is very unconscious of daily religious activities,” she said. “Throughout this experience, I have noticed myself becoming much more aware of God.”

Throughout our conversation, I find myself wanting to discuss the most obvious topic, but can’t bring it up without having to continually justify myself. Doesn’t she feel constricted and even oppressed by the practices she is assuming?

Wall’s candidness to discuss such issues validates my impression of her. She constantly reassures me to ask even the most probing questions and to present any debate, illustrating a maturity and intelligence uncommon for a 20-year-old.

“This experience has taught me to respect a woman’s decision to stay home with her children or wear a hijab or go out and become CEOs,” Wall said.

She finishes her sentence, as I notice a young woman staring at the back of Wall’s head.

Her eyes momentarily follow the outline of the brightly colored veil and then quickly move away. Instead of feeling sorry for Wall and assuming that the attention is warranted by feelings of resentment or fear, I soon wonder if the girl is instead intrigued by the hijab.

Wall admits to only showing her hair in the most intimate of settings, and I realize that I’m slightly jealous of someone who respects something I easily take for granted.

Comments

158 comments
Your name
Wed Jun 10 2009 18:59
Thank you for the prespective, Mrs. Wall!
JC
Wed Jun 10 2009 17:39
I am a Muslim woman and I wear hijab. Although I appreciate the underlying feelings that would prompt this youngn woman, or anyone else, do undertake these "experiments", I feel that somebody needs to point out how American Muslim women actually feel about these kinds of things. Many of us feel somewhat insulted by these experiments, because the underlying assumption seems to be that we cannot speak for ourselves or perhaps that we cannot be trusted to truthfully relate our experiences? Why couldn't this young woman have talked to American Muslim women about their experiences or maybe even hung out with them or followed them to observe people's reactions? Some of the assumptions being made here are borderline bizarre, like the thing about walking around with your arms down or crossed over your chest. Huh?! I think there are a LOT of assumptions being made about what "Muslim women have to do" that are not based in fact. I'm not sure what all this has to do with staying at home and not working either. Are you aware that Muslim women work just like everyone else? Hang around with some Muslims! You'll find out how we live pretty quickly, and I think you'll all be surprised.

Again, I know that the intent here was probably good and some of her conclusions listed here are wonderful, but I think we need to move beyond this idea of Muslims= somebody else and Muslims women as voiceless people who need some white, non-Muslim person to speak for us.

David Williams
Wed Jun 10 2009 17:17
I think this will prove to be a great eye opening experience for her. One of the things that makes the human race great is the ability to empathize with others and have compassion. I believe she is finding out how great and practical the practices of Islam are and will find a very strong appreciation for it. Even Christian nun's cover and are modest till this day. This is a practice that has been abandoned recently, I hope that Allah guides her, through this experience to the true path and know that the main reason for this modesty in Islam is to prevent unwanted sexual glares and glances, of which people would find interest in a woman for her body and looks, not for her mind and personality. This is the greatest form of respecting yourself for a woman in a society that has began to make it "unnormal" if you don't show your skin, cleavage and hair. That beauty of a woman should be only kept for the one who will be able to act according to witnessing that....her husband!
Louis Bertmans
Tue Jun 9 2009 03:44
Only in the US (so called free world) this kind of problems exist. In Europe, we don't have any issues with women covering their heads or dressing in any other way.
Your name
Mon Jun 8 2009 02:25
First of all, Islam does NOT negate the efforts of ANY woman covering her hair, no matter her religion or lack thereof. Those who ridicule this woman for covering her hair, need to study history, other cultures, but most importantly, Islam. As a convert to Islam, I will say that I can appreciate this woman's efforts as it is not the easiest thing in the world to decide to cover your hair in this society.

Samuel is just a troll. Ignore him.

Lover of Truth
Sun Jun 7 2009 17:40
Keep up the good work Ms. Wall, you are inspiring to all.
renita burwell
Sun Jun 7 2009 16:58
Amen, Shayma. A person's religion and its practices are not for outsiders to experiment with just for the sake of curiousity! This is not a museum! Also I've known quite a few Muslims, none ever ran around with their eyes cast down or folded their arms to hide their body. If they did cross their arms, it meant they were mad as hell and you had better run and fast. If Spencer wants to present a more modest appearance than what is necessary in American society, then let her do so. But do it in a way that doesn't make you appear to be something you're not.
Nikolai Royas
Sun Jun 7 2009 16:55
i found this story incredibly fascinating. absolutly remarkable. this young woman should be congradulated on her maturity and forthright attitude.
Marion
Sun Jun 7 2009 13:05
I think it takes a lot of strength to do what this young women is doing. I hope it changes not only her mind but those around her. I am not a Muslim, but I would totally stand beside her and support her.

More people need to try to walk in other people's shoes before they judge them.

Marion
Sun Jun 7 2009 13:04
I think it takes a lot of strength to do what this young women is doing. I hope it changes not only her mind but those around her. I am not a Muslim, but I would totally stand beside her and support her.

More people need to try to walk in other people's shoes before they judge them.

Fayzah
Sun Jun 7 2009 00:10
“I just want to know what it’s like to walk in their shoes for a while.”
You'd be surprised at how many people are open or tolerant toward the idea of a woman covering herself up. More surprising yet is the level of hatred people can feel toward a complete stranger because she won't let you see her body/hair. What an interesting way to find out for yourself (a whole year)! I've seen something of the like on YouTube; a woman called the Non-Muslim Hijabi experiments with the veil.
By the way, I'm a Hijaabi AND a Trekkie!
Fayzah
Sat Jun 6 2009 23:19
“I just want to know what it’s like to walk in their shoes for a while.”
You'd be surprised at how many people are open or tolerant toward the idea of a woman covering herself up. More surprising yet is the level of hatred people can feel toward a complete stranger because she won't let you see her body/hair. What an interesting way to find out for yourself (a whole year)! I've seen something of the like on YouTube; a woman called the Non-Muslim Hijabi experiments with the veil.
By the way, I am a Hijaabi AND a Trekkie!
Amane
Sat Jun 6 2009 22:13
You know ,i think what she did was great as for me im a muslim, that is having a hard time wearing the hijab ,it takes alot .
Sarah
Sat Jun 6 2009 18:26
So Wall chooses to do so and I don't think its a big deal. She wanted to know what it feels like and she knows now. Every culture and religion has its good sides and bad sides...or at least the bad sides that are preceived by the other groups. Maybe next time, Wall can try to wear an Indian or scottish outfit to see how that feels like too.

I think what Wall did is not the biggest story of the day. But I do respect her stand on how each of us need to be more tolerant and respectful to any culture, religion, race, color etc. Would be treat them better if we were blind and didnt see what they were like? Or would they treat them better only because they talk like us, dress like us and act like us. Also instead of impolitely staring at any minority group, we should befriend them if possible. You will be amazed hearing their stories on their practices, holidays, traditions. The differences in such humble practices makes the world exciting, rich, etc

Sarah
Sat Jun 6 2009 18:26
So Wall chooses to do so and I don't think its a big deal. She wanted to know what it feels like and she knows now. Every culture and religion has its good sides and bad sides...or at least the bad sides that are preceived by the other groups. Maybe next time, Wall can try to wear an Indian or scottish outfit to see how that feels like too.

I think what Wall did is not the biggest story of the day. But I do respect her stand on how each of us need to be more tolerant and respectful to any culture, religion, race, color etc. Would be treat them better if we were blind and didnt see what they were like? Or would they treat them better only because they talk like us, dress like us and act like us. Also instead of impolitely staring at any minority group, we should befriend them if possible. You will be amazed hearing their stories on their practices, holidays, traditions. The differences in such humble practices makes the world exciting, rich, etc

Lulu
Sat Jun 6 2009 16:01
Oh ya Allah Shayma,

Chill out please. Why is it that whenever a non-Muslim shows remote interest in anything Islamic, some Muslims have to react in a very emotionally centered manner and cry disrespect.

If anything, we should be more welcoming of their interest, you never know, but this experience is one that might have left a positive impact on her. She's obviously developed an appreciation for it. Growing up, I had non-Muslim friends who practiced Ramadan with me. Did I get all bent out of shape over it? No! It made me happy. InshalAllah, Allah will reward them for it!

Say mashaAllah, alhamdullilah. May Allah continue to guide this young woman.

Salman
Sat Jun 6 2009 14:11
Shayma, calm down please. The girl in the story said she wanted to know what it was like to walk in the shoes of a hijabi girl, to have to wear modest clothing and to put up with the stares, the insults, sneers, remarks, etc. It didn't say that she was doing this to understand Islam better. She simply wanted to know more about the outside, external pressures that hijabis have to put up with. I've been a Muslim all my life, born in Canada and I've lived all over USA and Canada [including Texas] and for sure I would have just assumed that Spencer is a Muslim, judging by her appearance. Yes this is an experiment for her, its one that she is free to do, and she isn't the first non-Muslim woman in the western hemisphere to try such an experiment. Live and let live, please.
NA
Sat Jun 6 2009 13:46
I must disagree with Shayma as I think she misses the point of the article. As a 24-year old Muslim woman who has been wearing hijab for nearly a decade now- by choice, might I add- I think it was a big step for Wall to decide to put it on just to see what it feels like; the stares, the assumptions, the questions, the attention- it's not easy to deal with being singled-out sometimes (especially airports), but it's something that we hijab-wearing women have to deal with. I think through this experience Wall was able understand why Muslim women wear hijab, and I hope more non-Muslims try to educate themselves to understand us better and widen their perspectives.
Shayma
Sat Jun 6 2009 08:30
To add to my previous comment. Firstly, Muslim women are allowed to move their arms when they walk, that's ridiculous. Secondly, the Prophet's (PBUH) first wife, Khadija, was a businesswoman who was required deal with men in her trade negotiations as well as the men who worked for her. As stated earlier, without a Muslim source behind your article, your information is baseless and incorrect. Please contact a local mosque or Muslim student association at a local university to get accurate information.
Shayma
Sat Jun 6 2009 08:18
What is this?!? Islam is a social experiment? What about those of us who actually live this life? This is a pathetic insulting attempt at trying to understanding an entire religion, void of the devotion behind the acts. Without devotion the acts are meaningless and misunderstood. You want to know what it's like to be a Muslim, well ask me or the thousands of other Muslims who live in North America. You can't rely on the experiment of some random Christian who doesn't have the vaguest concept of the ideas behind Islamic teachings. I'm disappointed you would even print this story. It's an insult.






log out