College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students Jobs and internships for students -

ACLU expresses concern over creationism in schools

Religious freedom, civil rights and curriculum discussed at conference

By Ben Wermund

Daily Texan Staff

Print this article

Published: Monday, August 3, 2009

Updated: Monday, August 3, 2009

With a battle brewing over the Texas State Board of Education’s potential to emphasize the importance of the Bible and the Christian faith in American history classes, American Civil Liberties Union members are expressing deep concern.

“On every single front, Texas is the least progressive state I’ve ever lived in and the biggest issue I see here is this insidious business of slipping it into the schools where we have vulnerable minds and peer pressure to boot,” said ACLU member Russell La Claire. “I am deeply concerned about that.”

The Texas affiliate of the ACLU held their annual meeting Saturday, focusing on religious freedom in Texas in light of recent changes made to the science curriculum by the board of education, as well as potential social studies changes.

In March, the board voted to allow creationist revisions of science course material, by altering language in the curriculum that indicated the “sufficiency and insufficiency” of evolutionist theories. The ACLU testified against the measure. 

“It’s the climate in Texas that makes us very interested in [religion],” said Dotty Griffith, the ACLU of Texas’ public education director. “We are always against any initiative of government-imposed religion. We’re all in favor of teaching about religion, but we are not in favor of proselytizing or promoting one religion over another.”

Griffith said she is sure the ACLU will also testify against the potential social studies changes.

Last month, the board appointed six experts to review the social studies curriculum.

Three of the appointed reviewers suggested the emphasis on Christianity. One of them, David Barton, is a former vice chair of the state Republican Party and founder of WallBuilders, a group that promotes Christianity in American history; another is the Rev. Peter Marshall; and the third is Daniel Dreisbach, a professor of public affairs at American University.

Terri Burke, ACLU Texas director, said the experts are questionable.

“Our biggest concern, frankly, is the process by which they make these determinations,” Burke said. “Where do these experts come from? Who are these experts? Somebody who has been the co-chair of the state Republican Party is, in my opinion, not an expert on history.”

Susan Herman, the ACLU national president, assured members in her keynote speech Saturday that Texas is not the only state in the U.S. concerning the union.

“As I’ve been meeting people over the last couple days, with typical Texas pride, people have been telling me that you have the worst civil liberties violations in Texas,” Herman said. “But you have some competition.”

She listed a series of cases the ACLU has taken on in states ranging from Arkansas to Michigan and said that, even with the election of President Barack Obama, the ACLU still has work to do.

“Can the ACLU close up shop? Maybe put a nice banner across the door saying ‘Mission Accomplished,’” Herman asked as the audience that erupted in laughter and negative shouts. “We need the ACLU to keep pushing.” 

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

10 comments

Your name
Sat Sep 26 2009 13:19
While there are debates within the scientific community about Evolutionary Theory, wether or not evolution happens is not one of them. It is just as proven as gravity, plate tectonics, and all other scientific theories. There are no "big questions" about its validity within the scientific community at all. To say otherwise shows nothing more than your lack of understanding of the process that science goes through.
anton
Sat Sep 26 2009 11:09
...i'm ok with them teaching creationism....as long as they teach the koran...buddism...hinduism....etc...etc....for the people that THINK this country was founded as a "christian" country, i suggest you educate yourselves and read some actual history.......
neoatg
Fri Sep 25 2009 21:57
It’s a sad day when faith based opinions over take logical reasoning. Religion has No place in the science or history classroom. Three of these "experts" had a clear agenda all throughout this process and it quite sad to see that a school board can be so proud to provide an inferior education. It is not a public school’s job to teach faith based ideals that is the job of a church or holy center. These people have such fragile faith that they can’t help but attack science as a threat to their control of others.
John McMackin
Wed Aug 19 2009 14:25
The ACLU certainly violates every one in America please close up. If Barack Obama is your poster child.He is
the devil for sure as people like you endorse abortion and gay marriage and everthing that is bad"
Blackout
Tue Aug 18 2009 13:40
In response to Randy Reynoldson, above...It is certainly worth studying the private writings of our founders, but it is also important to understand the difference between what these men thought privately at various points in their lives, and what they acted upon publically when standing as the leaders of our Great Nation. This same John Adams, for example, signed the following statement into Law: "[T]he Government of the United States of America is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion..." (Treaty of Tripoli, 1796-1797) The idea that citizens might privately hold religious beliefs that are in fact IRRELEVANT to the public acts of our Government was kind of THE WHOLE POINT behind Wall of Separation (as Jefferson described it) between the Church and the State.
Your name
Thu Aug 13 2009 13:25
Al, there is no way to approach the question of creation v. evolution without being religiously motivated. The creationist are motivated by the desire to see the truth propagated and God exalted as is His right. The evolutionists are motivated by the desire to discredit God and deny His existence, so as to exalt themselves into His place.
Randy Reynoldson
Fri Aug 7 2009 08:28
John Adams

SIGNER OF THE DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE; JUDGE; DIPLOMAT; ONE OF TWO SIGNERS OF THE BILL OF RIGHTS; SECOND PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES

The general principles on which the fathers achieved independence were the general principles of Christianity. I will avow that I then believed, and now believe, that those general principles of Christianity are as eternal and immutable as the existence and attributes of God.1

There are many more quotes on the record made by the founding fathers. Should not these papers and statements by studied as well. This would give a TOTAL picture of how our country is formed. Now, if the Bible is nothing more than a book, what do people have fear from it? The Bible is the most Feared Book in the World.

Al Cibiades
Wed Aug 5 2009 12:51
To say that these "experts" are questionnable is a major understatement. Barton is a dominionist propagandist, who claims that there is no separation of church and state, and claims history has been misread. Of course, he backs this up with an incredible series of lies and distortions of history and reality that have been documented in detail. To place this known fraud and liar on an education board to push his theorcratic agenda is ludicrous.

As far as science education is concerned, students should be taught science, not the perversions, distortions, misinformation and religiously motivated lies that the creationists have been pushing.

Your name
Tue Aug 4 2009 13:57
Darwinsm is as accepted in the scientific community as a Sun centric Universe and gravity. There is so much evidence supporting it and so little that can even be considered as questioning it that it is generally accepted within the science community. All over the world it is accepted by scientists in Iraq, Egypt, Western Europe, Eastern Europe Australia, japan etc.... The only ones who oppose it are religious fundamentalists of various flavors. Religion needs to be kept out of the classroom except where it is relavent in a historical context. And no our constitution was NOT founded on Biblical principals. It was founded on values that society shares with Religions but the establishment of the separation of church and state is clear and it still msakes sense today to maintain the separation in light of all the ridiculous positions of the religious extremists and their deisire to impose their beliefs on the larger population.
comprehensive information
Mon Aug 3 2009 13:14
History experts are questionable if they are from a political party, so is Darwinism (there are big questions , gaps and unproven theories.). The ACLU needs to acknowledge things that are questionable in their side as well, not the selective nonsense they are basing their own politics on. Information from all sides with full disclosures of weakness needs to be the way forward. That is sound judgement. You can't be the ACLU and censor things you don't agree with because it doesn't fit your agenda. I would rather have more comprehensive information than censored and limited information. This isn't an atheist country, and no one is pushing for national religion so people need to lighten up.






log out